What is English nationalism?

Liberal Democrat Vincent Cable has upset the folks over at the Campaign for an English Parliament with a remark in his new Demos pamphlet, Multiple Identities: Living with the New Politics of Identity.

The threat to harmonious social relations in Britain comes from those who insist that multiple identity, including Britishness, is not possible: white supremacists, English nationalists, Islamic fundamentalists. This is the opposition and they have to be confronted.

An important element in that confrontation is the assertion of a sense of Britishness. British patriotism went out of fashion with people of more liberal disposition when it was associated with imperial arrogance and racial superiority. Those days have long gone and there is now an important national component of our identity, within an open and diverse society, in which we should take pride. (Demos)

The CEP’s Gareth responds:

I am an English nationalist and I don’t much like being lumped into the same bracket as white supremacists and Islamic fundamentalists. I call myself a nationalist because I want to see an English parliament and government. An important part of recognising the multiple identities of the British Isles is in recognising England’s right to the political self-determination afforded to Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland.

Why does Mr Cable level the accusation at English nationalists and not Scottish or Welsh nationalists?

Mr Cable would do well to address his own prejudices before casting stones. (CEP)

Interestingly, Mr Cable’s definition of English nationalism seems to be slightly different to Gareth’s.

In the UK, hostility to asylum seekers and other immigrants, and suspicion of the EU, have a powerful appeal to English nationalists. In two successive general elections the Conservatives have chosen to focus on these issues rather than the traditional right-wing agenda of tax cutting and privatisation.While it has not paid them much by way of political dividends, they undoubtedly identified grievances which had troubled many voters. Indeed, the future of British politics may well revolve around the question of whether these expressions of identity come to dominate the traditional Right, the Conservatives, or are channelled through parties like UKIP or the BNP.

So English nationalism means the Conservatives, UKIP and the BNP, all avowedly British parties. Indeed, the philosophy Cable describes is if anything the identical to the ‘imperial arrogance and racial superiority’ which he says was once associated with Britishness.

So why label this kind of chauvinism as exclusively English? English identity it seems is the scapegoat for Britain’s imperial legacy. This allows Cable to avoid the deeper questions about whether British institutions has sloughed off that legacy sufficiently to provide a sound basis for modern democratic citizenship.


Posted

in

,

by

Tags:

Comments

6 responses to “What is English nationalism?”

  1. CEP News Blog avatar

    Vince Cable MP

    Vincent Cables remarks on English nationalists reported on this blog (here) are causing ripples.

  2. Little Man in a Toque avatar

    English first, British second

    It was with Helen’s recent post on British values in mind that I sat on my flight back to England reading the CRE’s paper ‘Citizenship and Belongning: What is Britishness?’ (pdf). It has long been my view that the British…

  3. Little Man in a Toque avatar

    English first, British second

    It was with Helen’s recent post on British values in mind that I sat on my flight back to England reading the CRE’s paper ‘Citizenship and Belongning: What is Britishness?’ (pdf). It has long been my view that the British…

  4. notirish avatar
    notirish

    You wanna know what English Nationalism is about; http://www.w3.ukgateway.net/aaa/

  5. Tom Griffin avatar

    “Belt a Celt” -very clever.
    By the way I used to work with Peter Kelly at the Irish World. Just what exactly did he do to bring down your wrath on the entire Celtic world?

  6. Andrew Clarke avatar
    Andrew Clarke

    English nationalism is about the recognition and promotion of the English speaking people native to the area recognised as England, and the ethnic, historical,cultural and common ties which bind us together as an independent nation. The concept of the English nation is older than that of the “British nation” and the self determination rightly being granted for Scotland and Wales can not be denied our own people.
    Andrew Clarke
    English Democrats

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *